How much does a roof replacement cost in Florida?

What a 'square' is, and why quotes use it

Roofing is priced per square — 100 square feet of roof surface, not of floor area. A single-storey 2,000 sq ft house with a typical hip roof is usually 22–26 squares once pitch and overhangs are counted. A two-storey 2,000 sq ft house has half the footprint and can be as little as 12–16. This is why a 'cost per home' number is close to meaningless on its own, and why the first thing to compare between two quotes is the square count, not the price.

What moves the number up

Pitch above 6:12 adds roughly 15–25% — steep roofs need staging and slow everything down. A second storey adds about 15% in labour, a third closer to 30%. Complex geometry — valleys, dormers, hips, skylights — adds another 15–25%. Tearing off a second layer roughly doubles disposal weight and the labour that goes with it. Permit fees run about $250–$450 in Hillsborough, $300–$550 in Pinellas, $180–$320 in Pasco, $200–$400 in Polk and $300–$800 in Orange County, where they are valuation-based. On tile, whether the existing tiles can be salvaged and relaid is worth thousands.

What it costs per square, by material

Architectural shingle runs roughly $500–$850 per square installed in these markets. Concrete tile is about $1,000–$2,000 and clay $1,400–$2,800. Standing-seam metal is $800–$1,500, while exposed-fastener 5V crimp sits below that at $650–$1,200. Low-slope systems are priced by area instead: modified bitumen $5–$9 per square foot, TPO $6–$11. Watch for supply-house pricing quoted per square on metal — those figures are usually material only, and installation adds another 40–60%.

Why the numbers you find online are lower

Homeowner-reported averages put Tampa roof replacement around $13,400 and Orlando around $10,500. Florida contractors' own published guides run 30–60% higher. Both are honest. The aggregator averages mix partial replacements, single-slope repairs and insurance-scope work in with full tear-offs, which pulls them down. A complete tear-off-to-deck replacement with a code-compliant sealed deck sits at the upper end of those ranges, not the middle — and that is the job being quoted here.

The line item most quotes hide

Decking. Nobody knows how much rotten plywood is under a Florida roof until the old roof comes off. An honest quote states the per-sheet price up front so the number can't move arbitrarily on the day. Ask for it in writing.

Does insurance change the price?

It changes who pays, not what it costs. If a covered storm caused the damage, your carrier's scope and your deductible determine your share. Florida law prohibits a contractor from offering to cover or rebate your deductible, so any quote built around that is one you should walk away from.

Is the cheapest quote ever the right one?

Sometimes. But check that the cheap one includes tear-off rather than a layover, a code-compliant secondary water barrier, new drip edge and valley metal, and the permit. Those four items are where the money disappears from a low bid.

Need this doing rather than reading about? Roof Replacement — Shingle re-roof $11k–$20k · free inspection.